US Court Seeks Delhi Courts’ Assistance to Serve Summons on Ajit Doval and Former RAW Chief in Pannun Lawsuit
The United States District Court for the Southern District of New York has directed the transmission of summonses and related judicial documents through three district courts in Delhi to National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) chief Samant Goel.
The development concerns a civil lawsuit filed by Gurpatwant Singh Pannun in 2024, alleging a conspiracy to assassinate him in the United States. The allegations against the named defendants remain allegations and have not been established by a judicial finding.
In its November 2026 orders, the US court authorised an alternative mechanism for serving the two officials after the conventional process through India's designated Central Authority under the Hague Convention was unsuccessful. The court has requested assistance from the Indian judicial system to facilitate delivery of the documents.
Legal Topic
Area of Law: Civil Procedure and Private International Law
Sub-topic: Service of Foreign Judicial Process, International Judicial Cooperation and Cross-Border Civil Litigation
Core Legal Issue
The central legal question is whether summons issued by a foreign civil court can be transmitted to Indian district courts for service on defendants residing in India, particularly when the ordinary procedure under the Hague Convention has not resulted in service.
The dispute involves the interaction between the Hague Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents and India's Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. It also raises questions about the procedural requirements governing the service of foreign judicial documents within Indian territory.
What Did the Court Decide?
US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla granted Pannun's application on November 9, 2026, permitting service of summons on Doval and Goel through the Indian judicial system.
A subsequent order dated November 13, 2026, specified the courts through which the documents were to be transmitted:
-
Patiala House District Court: To facilitate service on Ajit Doval.
-
Dwarka District Court: To facilitate service on Samant Goel.
-
Tis Hazari District Court: Also designated for service on Samant Goel.
The US court directed its Clerk to transmit the summonses and accompanying judicial documents through international mail or courier. It also requested the receiving courts to facilitate service according to applicable Indian procedures and provide a written record of the steps undertaken.
Importantly, the orders concern the procedure for delivering legal documents. They do not establish the allegations against the defendants or determine their liability.
Key Legal Points
-
Foreign summons in India: Section 29(c) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, provides a mechanism for receiving summonses issued by qualifying foreign civil courts.
-
Transmission between courts: Order V Rule 21 of the CPC provides for the transmission of summonses to courts having jurisdiction over the place where a defendant resides.
-
Hague Convention Article 19: Allows the application of domestic procedures permitting alternative methods of transmitting foreign judicial documents.
-
Alternative service: The US court authorised the Indian-courts route after earlier attempts through the designated Central Authority had failed.
-
No determination on liability: Permission to serve summons does not amount to acceptance of the plaintiff's allegations or a finding against the defendants.
Relevant Law
Indian Law
-
Section 29(c), Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Service of foreign summonses.
-
Order V Rule 21, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Service of summons where the defendant resides within the jurisdiction of another court.
-
Government of India Notification No. G.S.R. 24(E), January 13, 2009 – Extends Section 29 to civil courts in countries that are parties to the Hague Convention.
International and US Law
-
Article 19, Hague Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents.
-
Article 5, Hague Convention – Conventional channels for service of judicial documents.
-
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(f) – Service of process in a foreign country.
The US court also considered judicial precedents, including Water Splash, Inc. v. Menon (2017), while examining the relationship between the Hague Convention and domestic service procedures.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff – Gurpatwant Singh Pannun
Pannun argued that service through Indian courts was legally permissible under Article 19 of the Hague Convention and the relevant provisions of India's CPC.
He maintained that Section 29(c) and Order V Rule 21 allowed foreign civil court summonses to be transmitted to Indian courts for delivery to defendants residing within their jurisdiction.
He also relied on previous unsuccessful attempts to serve the defendants through the Indian Central Authority.
Defendants and Government of India
The court's November 9 order records the procedural history and the unsuccessful attempts to serve the defendants. It also discusses the response received from India's Central Authority.
However, the order does not record a final determination of the defendants' substantive defence to the assassination allegations. The US Department of State informed the court that it took no position on the proposed service through Indian courts.
Why Does It Matter?
The development highlights the importance of international judicial cooperation when civil litigation involves defendants residing outside the jurisdiction of the court hearing the case.
For Indian courts, the matter concerns the operation of Section 29(c) and Order V Rule 21 of the CPC in facilitating the service of foreign judicial documents.
It also illustrates how Article 19 of the Hague Convention can operate alongside domestic procedural law to provide an additional route for cross-border service.
For defendants in international civil litigation, the distinction between receiving a summons and being held legally responsible is particularly important. Service of process provides procedural notice and an opportunity to participate in proceedings; it does not decide the merits of a claim.
The case also demonstrates that unsuccessful attempts through one service mechanism do not necessarily prevent a litigant from seeking another legally recognised method.
Legal Takeaway
The US court's orders establish a procedural route for transmitting summonses to Ajit Doval and Samant Goel through designated Delhi district courts under Article 19 of the Hague Convention and relevant provisions of India's CPC. However, authorisation of service must not be confused with a judicial finding on the allegations in the underlying lawsuit. The substantive claims remain to be adjudicated.
Sources
Primary Sources:
Additional Sources: