UK High Court Upholds Costs Ruling in Decade-Long Boundary Dispute, Leaving 95-Year-Old Woman Facing £1 Million Legal Bill
A decade-long property boundary dispute in Kent, England, has ended with another setback for a 95-year-old woman after the High Court dismissed her appeal against a legal costs order.
The dispute involved Mary Egan and her neighbours, Neil and Fiona Morgan, over approximately 45 square metres of land along the boundary of their properties in Sissinghurst, Kent.
Although Egan succeeded in establishing that her neighbours had trespassed by installing fences on her property, she failed to secure her preferred outcome concerning the actual boundary line. The High Court has now upheld the decision requiring both sides to bear their own legal expenses, leaving Egan facing a reported legal bill exceeding £1 million.
Legal Topic
Area of Law: Property Law and Civil Litigation
Sub-topic: Land Boundary Disputes, Trespass and Allocation of Legal Costs
Core Legal Issue
The central legal question was whether a party who succeeds on a trespass claim but fails to obtain the principal relief sought in a property boundary dispute should nevertheless be treated as the successful party for the purpose of recovering legal costs.
The High Court also had to consider whether the opposing party's inappropriate conduct during litigation justified overturning the earlier decision on costs.
What Did the High Court Decide?
In Mary Egan v Neil Morgan & Anor, [2026] EWHC 2946 (BP), Mr Justice Tappin dismissed the appeal on 16 November 2026.
The High Court found no legal error in the original judge's assessment that neither party had achieved an overall victory. The court considered the following aspects:
-
Egan succeeded in establishing trespass involving parts of the fences and the neighbours' entry onto her land.
-
The Morgans' claim for damages against Egan was rejected.
-
Egan failed to establish her principal argument that the boundary ran through the middle of the hedge.
-
Her request for an injunction requiring the removal of the third fence was refused.
-
The court considered that the overall result did not justify treating either side as the successful party for costs purposes.
The original court had awarded Egan £1,300 in damages, £1,300 in aggravated damages and £3,250 in damages instead of an injunction.
The High Court therefore upheld the decision that there should be no general order requiring either side to pay the other's legal costs.
Key Legal Points
-
Overall success matters: Winning individual claims or obtaining damages does not automatically make a party the successful litigant.
-
Non-monetary relief is relevant: Courts can consider whether a party secured the declaration or injunction that formed the central part of their case.
-
Judicial discretion over costs: Decisions on costs are primarily matters of judicial evaluation and discretion.
-
Litigation misconduct: Abusive behaviour may influence costs orders, particularly where it increases legal expenses or is sufficiently serious to justify a proportionate penalty.
-
Appeal courts exercise restraint: An appellate court will not interfere with a costs decision merely because it might have reached a different conclusion.
Relevant Law
Civil Procedure Rules 1998 – CPR 44.2
This provision governs the court's discretion when deciding who should pay litigation costs. It allows the court to consider all relevant circumstances, including the parties' conduct and the degree of success achieved by each side.
Civil Procedure Rules – CPR 52.21(3)(a)
This provision concerns the appellate court's power to allow an appeal where the lower court's decision was wrong.
Relevant Judicial Precedents
-
Widlake v BAA [2009] EWCA Civ 1256 – Addresses the relevance of litigation misconduct when determining costs.
-
Walsh v Singh [2011] EWCA Civ 80 – Recognises that sufficiently serious misconduct may justify a proportionate costs penalty even without a direct increase in costs.
-
Roache v News Group Newspapers Ltd [1998] EMLR 161 – Relevant to the restraint exercised by appellate courts when reviewing discretionary decisions.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant – Mary Egan
Egan argued that she should be recognised as the successful party because the Morgans' original damages claim had failed and the court had found that they committed trespass.
Her legal team also challenged the treatment of the Morgans' conduct during the proceedings. They argued that the neighbours' inappropriate communications, lengthy submissions and litigation behaviour should have resulted in a more favourable costs order for her.
She sought an order requiring the Morgans to pay her legal costs on the indemnity basis.
Respondents – Neil and Fiona Morgan
Neil Morgan, representing himself and his wife, opposed the appeal.
The respondents maintained that the original judge had correctly assessed the overall outcome. They relied on Egan's failure to establish her preferred boundary position and her unsuccessful attempt to secure an injunction requiring the removal of the third fence.
They also disputed the argument that their conduct justified changing the costs order.
Why Does It Matter?
The judgment highlights the financial consequences that can arise when property disputes become prolonged litigation.
For property owners, the decision demonstrates that establishing trespass or obtaining damages does not necessarily mean recovering the legal expenses incurred in pursuing a claim. Courts may examine the entire outcome, including whether the principal relief sought was actually granted.
It also provides an important reminder about litigation conduct. Although abusive communications towards lawyers, judges and court staff were expressly criticised, such behaviour does not automatically result in an adverse costs order. Its relevance must be assessed in the context of the proceedings and the applicable legal principles.
For legal practitioners, the decision reinforces the importance of assessing the practical objectives of litigation before commencing or continuing proceedings. The financial consequences of a boundary dispute can become disproportionate to the value of the land involved.
Legal Takeaway
The High Court's decision in Egan v Morgan reinforces that success in a civil dispute is assessed by examining the overall outcome rather than simply counting individual victories or damages awarded. Under CPR 44.2, courts retain broad discretion over costs, and even serious litigation misconduct does not automatically require one party to pay the other's legal expenses.
Sources
Primary Source:
- Mary Egan v Neil Morgan & Anor [2026] EWHC 2946 (BP) – High Court Judgment, 16 November 2026 (The National Archives, Find Case Law).
Additional Sources: