Calcutta High Court Confirms Death Penalty in Hooghly Child Rape and Murder Case, Enhances Victim Compensation to ₹15 Lakh
A Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court has confirmed the capital punishment awarded to 45-year-old Ashok Singh for the sexual assault and murder of a five-year-old girl in West Bengal’s Hooghly district. Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray dismissed the convict’s appeal and accepted the State’s death reference, affirming the January 2025 conviction and sentence passed by the Exclusive POCSO Court in Chinsurah.
The crime occurred in November 2024 in the Gurap area, where Singh lived a few houses away from the child’s family and was affectionately addressed by her as "Jethu" (uncle). After the child went missing, a search led her parents and neighbours to Singh's home, where she was found unconscious and bleeding; she was later declared dead at Dhaniakhali Rural Hospital. Beyond confirming the death sentence, the High Court also intervened to ensure financial justice for the bereaved family after noticing that the State had failed to disburse the compensation initially ordered by the trial court.
Legal Topic
Area of Law: Criminal Law
Sub-topic: Capital Punishment / Child Sexual Offences (POCSO)
Core Legal Issue
The High Court had to determine two primary questions: first, whether the prosecution’s chain of circumstantial and forensic evidence proved Ashok Singh's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt; and second, whether the offence met the stringent "rarest of rare" threshold under Indian criminal jurisprudence to justify confirming the death penalty over life imprisonment without remission.
In evaluating the sentence, the Bench also examined whether there were any viable prospects for the convict's reformation, alongside the aggravating factors of extreme brutality, breach of trust, and the enduring trauma inflicted on the victim's family.
What Did the Court / Authority Decide?
The Division Bench upheld both the conviction and the death sentence, ruling that the trial court's judgment suffered from no legal or factual infirmity. However, to protect the convict's statutory appellate rights, the High Court stayed the execution of the judgment for three months to allow him time to approach the Supreme Court.
Key directions and rulings include:
-
Confirmation of Sentence: The Court accepted Death Reference No. 2 of 2025 and dismissed Criminal Appeal (DB) 328 of 2025, holding that even life imprisonment for the remainder of the convict's natural life without remission would be inadequate given the depravity of the act.
-
Enhanced Compensation: Taking note that the West Bengal government had not yet paid the ₹10 lakh compensation awarded by the trial court, the Bench enhanced the amount to ₹15 lakh and directed the State to pay the child's parents within two months.
-
Legal Aid Compliance: The Registrar General and the correctional home superintendent were directed to furnish a copy of the judgment to Singh, inform him of his right to appeal to the Supreme Court and access free legal aid, and file a compliance report within seven days.
Key Legal Points
-
Unbroken Chain of Circumstantial Evidence: The Court held that last-seen witness testimony—showing the accused luring the child with chocolates—combined with the recovery of her body inside his residence and DNA matches from forensic swabs left no missing link in the prosecution's case.
-
Mandatory Reformation Inquiry: Following constitutional precedent, the Bench conducted a structured inquiry into the convict's potential for reform by reviewing his medical, psychological, and probation officer reports before ruling out alternative punishments.
-
Lack of Remorse and Breach of Trust: The judges emphasized that exploiting the trust of a child who viewed him as a family elder, coupled with complete denial and zero remorse during his court examination, demonstrated an entrenched criminal mindset.
-
Victimological Considerations in Sentencing: The Bench underscored that the severe, ongoing psychological trauma suffered by the victim's parents—noting that the child's mother fainted while testifying during the trial—must be weighed alongside the gravity of the crime.
Relevant Law
-
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS): Sections 64(2), 65(2) (punishment for rape of a woman under twelve years of age), 66 (punishment for causing death or resulting in persistent vegetative state of victim), and 103(1) (punishment for murder).
-
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO): Section 6(1) (punishment for aggravated penetrative sexual assault).
-
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) / Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC): Section 351 BNSS (corresponding to Section 313 CrPC, governing the examination of the accused) and statutory death reference confirmation procedures.
-
Precedent: Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (establishing the "rarest of rare" doctrine and the requirement to balance aggravating and mitigating circumstances, including the probability of reformation).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant / Convict
Appearing through court-appointed legal aid counsel, Ashok Singh denied all involvement in the crime. In his statutory statement before the trial court, he claimed he had returned from work at 6:45 PM, changed his clothes, and was sitting outside on the road in front of his house without knowing what had transpired in the locality. While admitting that the search party found the child inside his home, he contended that he had no knowledge of how she got there or how she sustained her injuries.
Respondent / State of West Bengal
Represented by Special Public Prosecutor Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee, the State submitted that the ocular, medical, and forensic evidence conclusively established Singh’s guilt. The prosecution pointed to post-mortem findings confirming homicidal intracranial haemorrhage caused by the child's head being repeatedly struck against a hard surface following violent sexual assault, as well as forensic reports matching Singh's DNA to swabs taken from the victim. The State argued that the extreme brutality and lack of any scope for reform warranted confirming the maximum penalty.
Why Does It Matter?
This judgment illustrates how Indian appellate courts apply the modern death penalty framework under the newly enacted Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) alongside the POCSO Act. Rather than relying solely on the visceral horror of a crime against a child, the Calcutta High Court demonstrated strict adherence to Supreme Court guidelines by formally evaluating psychological and probation records to establish the impossibility of rehabilitation before confirming a death warrant. Additionally, the ruling serves as a sharp reminder to state administrations that victim compensation is an enforceable legal duty that cannot be neglected while the State prosecutes an offender.
Legal Takeaway
Even in heinous cases involving the sexual assault and murder of a child, appellate courts must balance the brutality of the offence against formal medical and probation assessments of the convict's capacity for reform before confirming a death sentence. Simultaneously, courts will actively enforce statutory compensation schemes to ensure bereaved families receive timely financial support from the State.
Sources
Primary Source:
Judgment of the Calcutta High Court in State of West Bengal v. Ashok Singh with Ashok Singh v. State of West Bengal & Anr. (DR 2 of 2025 with CRA (DB) 328 of 2025), decided on November 17, 2026 by Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray.
Additional Sources:
-
Bar & Bench report on the Calcutta High Court verdict (November 18, 2026)
-
LiveLaw and LawChakra case coverage and judgment extracts (November 17, 2026)