International

Supreme Court Asked to Strip Federal Judges of Power to Strike Down Agency Rules Nationwide

By The Legal Alpha Web Desk 15 November 2026 7 min read
Supreme Court Asked to Strip Federal Judges of Power to Strike Down Agency Rules Nationwide

The Trump administration has petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to eliminate a long-standing judicial remedy known as "universal vacatur," which allows federal judges to invalidate unlawful government regulations nationwide.

In a petition for a writ of certiorari filed on October 14, 2026, in Department of Health and Human Services v. Texas Medical Association (Docket No. 26-491), the Department of Justice argued that when a federal court finds an agency rule unlawful, it should only be permitted to block the rule's enforcement against the specific plaintiffs who filed the lawsuit—not nullify the rule for the rest of the country.

The appeal stems from an August 11, 2026, en banc ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. In that case, the Fifth Circuit invalidated portions of federal rules implementing the No Surprises Act—a law protecting patients from unexpected out-of-network medical bills—and wiped those provisions off the books nationwide. Notably, the administration is not asking the Supreme Court to rescue the substance of the healthcare billing rules. Instead, it is using the appeal purely as a vehicle to curtail the remedial power of lower federal courts under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA).

Legal Topic

  • Area of Law: Administrative Law / Constitutional Law

  • Sub-topic: Judicial Review of Agency Action / Scope of Equitable and Statutory Remedies

Core Legal Issue

The central question presented to the Supreme Court is whether Section 706(2) of the Administrative Procedure Act—which directs a reviewing court to "hold unlawful and set aside" improper agency actions—authorizes federal judges to issue universal vacatur that nullifies a regulation for all non-parties nationwide.

The Court is also being asked to determine whether, even if vacatur is permitted under the statute, it must be treated as a discretionary equitable remedy subject to traditional limits rather than an automatic default whenever a rule is found unlawful.

What Did the Court / Authority Decide?

No final Supreme Court decision has been issued yet. The matter is currently at the petition stage, with the Supreme Court deciding whether to grant review (certiorari) and hear oral arguments.

  • What has been decided below: The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas and the full en banc Fifth Circuit ruled in favor of the Texas Medical Association, Tyler Regional Hospital, and several air-ambulance providers. Both courts held that federal agencies unlawfully distorted the methodology for calculating the "qualifying payment amount" (QPA)—the benchmark used to resolve payment disputes between insurers and out-of-network providers—and vacated the offending provisions nationwide.

  • What is still pending: The Supreme Court must decide whether to take up the Justice Department's petition (with initial response deadlines falling in mid-November 2026). If granted, the justices will issue a binding national ruling on the scope of judicial remedies under the APA.

Key Legal Points

  • Meaning of "Set Aside": Under 5 U.S.C. § 706(2), courts must "set aside" unlawful agency rules. For decades, federal courts have interpreted "set aside" as vacating the regulation entirely so it ceases to exist for anyone, rather than merely declining to apply it to the litigants in court.

  • Extension of Trump v. CASA: In 2025, the Supreme Court ruled in Trump v. CASA that federal courts generally lack authority under the Judiciary Act of 1789 to issue universal injunctions blocking executive policies for non-parties. However, the Court explicitly left unresolved whether the APA independently authorizes universal vacatur of agency rules. This petition directly asks the Court to close that gap.

  • Default Remedy vs. Equitable Discretion: Even if the Supreme Court declines to abolish vacatur outright, the administration is pushing a secondary argument: that vacatur is not mandatory. Under this view, courts would frequently leave unlawful rules in place ("remand without vacatur") while agencies attempt to fix legal defects.

  • Bipartisan Executive Interest: Limiting nationwide judicial blocks is a recurring goal across administrations. In 2023, the Biden administration raised similar objections to universal vacatur in United States v. Texas, though the Supreme Court resolved that immigration dispute on standing grounds without deciding the APA remedy question.

Relevant Law

  • Administrative Procedure Act (APA), 5 U.S.C. § 706(2): Governs judicial review of federal agency actions and instructs courts to "hold unlawful and set aside" rules that are arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law.

  • Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. § 703: Identifies traditional forms of legal proceedings (such as declaratory judgments or writs of injunction) available in administrative challenges.

  • No Surprises Act (42 U.S.C. § 300gg-111): The underlying statute governing out-of-network healthcare billing and the calculation of qualifying payment amounts.

  • Trump v. CASA (2025): Supreme Court precedent curtailing universal injunctions under traditional equity principles while reserving the question of APA vacatur.

Arguments of the Parties

  • Petitioner (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services / Department of Justice): The government contends that Section 706(2) simply directs courts to disregard an unlawful rule when deciding the specific case before them, not to erase the regulation from the Federal Register nationwide. It argues that traditional judicial power is limited to remedying injuries suffered by the actual parties in court, and that universal vacatur encourages "forum shopping" by allowing a single district judge to halt national policy.

  • Respondents (Texas Medical Association et al.) and State Amici: Healthcare providers—joined in the lower courts by a coalition of Republican-led states including Texas and Florida—argue that the text and history of the APA clearly empower courts to nullify invalid regulations across the board. State attorneys general warned the Fifth Circuit that stripping courts of vacatur power would "neuter" the APA and undermine a vital check against federal executive overreach.

Why Does It Matter?

If the Supreme Court adopts the administration's position, the practical balance of power between federal agencies, regulated industries, and the judiciary will shift dramatically.

Currently, when a trade association, advocacy group, or state successfully proves that a federal regulation violates the law, a single court ruling wipes out the rule for everyone. Without universal vacatur, an unlawful regulation could remain legally binding on millions of individuals and businesses across the country for years while separate lawsuits slowly wind through different regional circuits.

For businesses, hospitals, and consumers, challenging federal overreach would become vastly more expensive and fragmented. Rather than relying on an industry group to defeat an unlawful mandate once, every affected company or individual would either have to file their own lawsuit or join complex class actions just to avoid complying with a rule a federal court has already declared illegal. Because the ruling would apply regardless of which political party holds the White House, it would permanently insulate future administrations of both parties from rapid, nationwide judicial invalidation of their regulatory agendas.

Legal Takeaway

A judicial ruling that a federal regulation is unlawful does not automatically erase it unless the court has the power to vacate it nationwide. If the Supreme Court curbs universal vacatur under the Administrative Procedure Act, regulated businesses and individuals will no longer be able to rely on a single landmark lawsuit to shield them from invalid federal rules—forcing every affected party to seek court protection on their own while unlawful regulations remain active.

Sources

  • Primary Source: Petition for a Writ of Certiorari, United States Department of Health and Human Services, et al. v. Texas Medical Association, et al., U.S. Supreme Court Docket No. 26-491 (filed October 14, 2026); Opinion of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit (en banc), No. 23-40605 (decided August 11, 2026).

  • Additional Sources: Supreme Court of the United States Docket Filings; SCOTUSblog Case Analysis; O'Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law (Georgetown Law).