Supreme Court Dissolves 13-Year Marriage Under Article 142, Approves ₹75-Crore Comprehensive Settlement and Child Trust Structure
The Supreme Court of India has brought a close to a protracted, multi-front matrimonial battle between an estranged couple married since January 2013. On November 16, 2026, a division bench comprising Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and N. Kotiswar Singh invoked the Court's extraordinary constitutional authority under Article 142 to dissolve the 13-year marriage and record a comprehensive ₹75-crore global settlement.
The dispute, which spanned years and generated 14 separate civil, criminal, and domestic violence proceedings across courts in West Bengal, involved disagreements over alimony, shared household rights in Kolkata, and the custody of the couple's nine-year-old son (born in May 2017). Following judicial encouragement to explore an amicable resolution during the pendency of the appeal, the parties exchanged proposals and agreed to a structured financial and parenting framework. Senior Advocates Kapil Sibal and Sunil Fernandes appeared on behalf of the husband, while Senior Advocate Siddharth Agarwal represented the wife.
Legal Topic
Area of Law: Family Law and Constitutional Law Sub-topic: Irretrievable Breakdown of Marriage / Article 142 Jurisdiction / Permanent Alimony and Child Custody
Core Legal Issue
The central question before the Supreme Court was whether it should exercise its plenary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution to dissolve a marriage that had irretrievably broken down, simultaneously quashing a web of interconnected civil, matrimonial, and criminal litigations.
Additionally, the Court had to formalize a legally enforceable settlement mechanism that balanced permanent spousal alimony with long-term financial security, residential rights, and a structured co-parenting framework for a minor child, while resolving lingering disputes over the occupation of a shared matrimonial household.
What Did the Court / Authority Decide?
The Supreme Court granted a decree of divorce on November 16, 2026, incorporating the negotiated settlement terms directly into its binding judicial order. The key directions and conditions include:
-
Permanent Alimony and Property Handover: The husband must pay ₹30 crore to the wife as full and final permanent alimony via demand draft within one week of the order. This payment is tied simultaneously to the wife handing over the keys and vacant, peaceful possession of the family's residential property in Kolkata.
-
Creation of a ₹45-Crore Child Trust: An additional ₹45 crore is earmarked for the nine-year-old son. The mother will hold and manage these funds in trust on the child's behalf.
-
Conditional Residential Rights: Up to ₹5 crore from the child's ₹45-crore trust fund will be utilized to purchase a residential property, which will remain legally owned by the trust rather than the mother. The mother holds a conditional right to reside in this home until she remarries or the son turns 25, whichever comes first. If she remarries before the son turns 25, her right of residence terminates immediately; if she remains unmarried after he turns 25, her continued stay rests entirely at the son's discretion.
-
Parenting Plan and Dispute Resolution: The Court adopted the parenting plan submitted by the husband governing child access and visitation. If future disagreements arise over implementing or modifying the plan, both parents are legally required to attempt an amicable resolution in good faith—keeping the child's welfare paramount—before approaching a competent court for modifications.
-
Quashing of Pending Litigation: All 14 pending legal proceedings between the parties in West Bengal—encompassing domestic violence complaints, cross-FIRs, criminal prosecutions, civil suits, and matrimonial cases—were ordered closed.
Nothing remains pending in the Supreme Court; both parties are bound to execute the financial transfers and property handover within the stipulated one-week timeline.
Key Legal Points
-
Plenary Power to End Prolonged Litigation: Under Article 142 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court can bypass statutory waiting periods and procedural hurdles to dissolve a deadlocked marriage and quash related criminal and civil cases when doing so achieves complete justice.
-
Ring-Fencing Child Assets Through Trusts: By placing the ₹45-crore corpus and the ₹5-crore residential property under a trust owned by the child rather than transferring title directly to the custodial parent, the settlement protects the minor's long-term financial interests.
-
Balancing Shared Household Claims: Earlier in the litigation, the Calcutta High Court had ruled that a spouse cannot simultaneously occupy a shared matrimonial household and claim monthly monetary allowances for alternative accommodation. The final settlement resolves this friction by trading vacant possession of the Kolkata home for a structured trust-owned residence with clear sunset clauses tied to remarriage and the child's adulthood.
-
Mandatory Good-Faith Mediation Clause: Incorporating a binding requirement for parents to negotiate parenting disputes amicably before returning to court prioritizes the child's psychological stability and discourages reflexive re-litigation.
Relevant Law
-
Article 142 of the Constitution of India: Empowers the Supreme Court to pass any decree or order necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it.
-
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005: Governs claims for maintenance, monetary relief, and the right to reside in a shared household—issues that formed the core of the lower court proceedings before the final settlement.
-
Precedent Context (Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan, 2023): Established the constitutional parameters under which the Supreme Court exercises Article 142 to grant divorce on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage and quash ancillary criminal proceedings.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner / Husband The husband contended that the 13-year marriage had broken down beyond repair and that the proliferation of 14 civil and criminal cases warranted the Supreme Court's direct intervention under Article 142. Earlier in the dispute, he also challenged the wife's claim for ₹60,000 per month in alternative accommodation allowances while she continued to occupy two floors of their shared Kolkata residence.
Respondent / Wife The wife initially opposed the husband's plea for dissolution, with her pleadings highlighting unresolved disputes over maintenance, residential accommodation, rights in the shared household, child custody, and visitation. Following court-encouraged negotiations, however, she consented to the global settlement terms.
Why Does It Matter?
High-net-worth and deeply contested matrimonial disputes in India frequently fracture into dozens of parallel proceedings across family courts, magistrate courts, and High Courts, clogging the judicial system for years. This order illustrates how the Supreme Court increasingly utilizes Article 142 not merely to grant a divorce, but to act as a structural facilitator for complex, multi-tiered settlements.
For family law practitioners and litigants, the structure of this settlement offers a clear template for resolving contentious property and child-support deadlocks. Separating spousal alimony (₹30 crore) from a child's corpus (₹45 crore) via a formal trust—while tying residential rights to objective milestones like remarriage or the child turning 25—prevents future ambiguity over asset ownership and inheritance.
Legal Takeaway
When a marriage has irretrievably broken down and triggered multiple civil and criminal cases, the Supreme Court can invoke Article 142 to dissolve the union and terminate all parallel proceedings in one stroke. Structuring high-value settlements through dedicated child trusts and time-bound residential rights ensures that a minor's financial future remains protected long after the parents part ways.
Sources
Primary Source:
-
Order of the Supreme Court of India (Bench of Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and N. Kotiswar Singh), dated November 16, 2026.
Additional Sources:
-
Legal reporting on the Supreme Court proceedings and prior Calcutta High Court interim maintenance rulings (Hindustan Times, November 17, 2026).