Returning Stolen Funds Does Not Guarantee Bail in Cyber Fraud Cases, Rules Gurugram Court
A Sessions Court in Gurugram has dismissed the regular bail plea of Saurabh Pandey, an accused in an online banking fraud case involving ₹1,95,500. The defence sought his release on the ground that the defrauded amount had been repaid in full to the complainant and the private dispute stood settled.
The criminal case arose out of a complaint lodged by retired Indian Navy officer Prabhat Kumar Ghosh. According to the complaint, ₹1,95,500 was unauthorizedly debited from his Union Bank of India account across three separate transactions on September 26 and September 29. Afterward, Ghosh detected a malicious file named "RTO CHALLAN APK" on his mobile phone, which investigators suspect was used to compromise his device and access his banking credentials.
During the probe, police tracked the stolen money to two separate bank accounts: ₹99,500 was routed to an HDFC Bank account held by Manju Verma, the wife of co-accused Ajay Singh, while the remaining ₹96,000 landed in an Axis Bank account belonging to Akash Pandit. Investigators allege that Singh supplied his wife's account details to Pandey in exchange for monetary gain, withdrew the funds on Pandey's directions, and handed the cash to another associate, Sandeep, in Varanasi. Additional Sessions Judge Varsha Jain turned down Pandey's bail application, holding that a private financial compromise with the victim cannot override the broader public interest in prosecuting organized cybercrimes.
Legal Topic
Area of Law: Criminal Law / Cyber Law Sub-topic: Bail Jurisprudence / Cyber Financial Fraud and Mule Accounts
Core Legal Issue
The central question before the Gurugram Sessions Court was whether full repayment of defrauded money and an out-of-court settlement between the accused and the complainant entitle an accused to bail in a cyber fraud prosecution, particularly when the investigation is ongoing and the offence points toward a wider, commission-based network of mule bank accounts.
What Did the Court / Authority Decide?
Additional Sessions Judge Varsha Jain dismissed Saurabh Pandey's bail petition. The court refused to treat the ₹1.95 lakh refund or the private settlement with the complainant as a sufficient basis to grant liberty.
While rejecting the plea, the court made the following key observations and determinations:
-
Wider Harm Beyond Individual Loss: Drawing on High Court precedent, the court noted that cybercrime functions like a "silent virus" whose consequences extend far beyond an individual victim's financial loss. Such offences erode public trust in digital banking and expose countless unsuspecting citizens to financial vulnerability.
-
Gravity of the Alleged Role: The court took note of investigative material suggesting that Pandey actively facilitated the fraud by procuring bank accounts to route cheated funds in exchange for a 20% commission.
-
Incomplete Investigation and Absconding Co-Accused: The judge weighed the electronic evidence—specifically suspicious chats regarding bank transactions recovered from the phones of Pandey, Sandeep, and another co-accused, Monu Tiwari—alongside the fact that Tiwari remains absconding and the police probe is still underway.
The order strictly addresses Pandey's bail application during the investigation stage; the substantive criminal trial and determination of guilt remain pending.
Key Legal Points
-
Private Settlements Do Not Neutralize Public Offences: In cases involving systemic digital fraud, compensating the victim does not automatically wipe out criminal liability or compel a court to grant bail, as the offence affects society's broader financial security.
-
Scrutiny of Mule Account Facilitators: Courts treat individuals accused of sourcing and managing third-party bank accounts ("mule accounts") for a commission as integral links in cybercrime syndicates rather than peripheral actors.
-
Stage of Investigation Matters: When key suspects remain at large and digital trails are still being examined, courts are reluctant to release an accused who could potentially tamper with evidence, influence witnesses, or obstruct ongoing arrests.
-
Protection of Digital Trust: Judicial assessment of bail in cyber fraud cases explicitly factors in the need to preserve public confidence in electronic payment and banking infrastructure.
Relevant Law
-
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) — Section 483: Governs the powers of a High Court or Court of Session regarding the grant of regular bail in non-bailable offences, requiring courts to weigh the nature and gravity of the accusation, the severity of punishment, the risk of tampering with evidence, and the larger interest of the public.
-
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) — Section 318 (Cheating) and Section 61 (Criminal Conspiracy): Standard penal provisions invoked in coordinated financial cheating and impersonation schemes (corresponding to Sections 420 and 120B of the former Indian Penal Code).
-
Information Technology Act, 2000 — Sections 66C and 66D: Penalize identity theft and cheating by personation using computer resources, commonly applied in malware-assisted banking frauds such as malicious APK file intrusions.
(Note: Specific FIR section numbers were not reproduced in the available court report; the provisions above reflect the governing statutory framework applicable to such prosecutions.)
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant (Saurabh Pandey): Counsel Bhaskar Yadav submitted that Pandey had been falsely implicated in the case and pointed out that his name did not figure in the original First Information Report (FIR). The defence contended that the complainant had already been reimbursed the entire defrauded sum and the dispute stood amicably settled. Arguing that the trial was likely to take considerable time to conclude, counsel maintained that continued judicial custody served no useful purpose.
Respondent (State / Prosecution): Public Prosecutor Aakash Deep opposed the bail plea, contending that Pandey played an active operational role in the fraud by arranging bank accounts to receive the stolen money for a 20% commission and coordinating subsequent fund transfers and cash withdrawals. The prosecution relied on suspicious chats concerning bank transactions extracted from the mobile phones of Pandey, Sandeep, and Monu Tiwari. It further argued that the investigation was still incomplete, co-accused Monu Tiwari was yet to be arrested, and releasing Pandey on bail risked hampering the ongoing probe or enabling similar offences.
Why Does It Matter?
As malicious APK scams—often disguised as traffic challan notices or government alerts—surge across India, fraudsters increasingly rely on layered networks of rented or borrowed bank accounts to quickly move stolen money before victims can report the theft. A recurring strategy by accused middlemen upon arrest is to refund the specific complainant's money and seek bail on the strength of a compromise.
This ruling reinforces a clear judicial boundary: cyber fraud is not treated as a purely private monetary dispute between two individuals. For banks, investigators, and everyday digital banking users, the decision signals that courts are looking past individual restitution to examine the underlying infrastructure of cybercrime. For individuals approached to lend or arrange bank accounts in exchange for a percentage cut, the order underscores that acting as a financial conduit carries serious custodial consequences that cannot simply be bought off through a post-arrest refund.
Legal Takeaway
Repaying a cyber fraud victim and signing a settlement will not automatically secure bail. Courts evaluate cybercrime through the lens of broader public trust in digital banking, meaning accused facilitators—especially while co-accused remain absconding and investigations are active—face strict judicial scrutiny regardless of whether the victim has been compensated.
Sources
Primary Source:
-
Bail Order passed by Additional Sessions Judge Varsha Jain, District and Sessions Court, Gurugram (dismissing regular bail application of accused Saurabh Pandey).
Additional Sources:
-
Court proceedings and investigative details reported via The Times of India ("Gurgaon court rejects 'settlement' between accused & victim in cyberfraud case, denies bail", November 20, 2026) and The420.in ("Settlement Cannot Erase Cybercrime, Gurugram Court Rejects Bail Plea", November 20, 2026).