National

Orissa High Court: Live-in Relationships Can Attract Section 498A IPC Prosecution Where They Resemble Marriage

By The Legal Alpha Web Desk 20 November 2026 6 min read
Orissa High Court: Live-in Relationships Can Attract Section 498A IPC Prosecution Where They Resemble Marriage

The Orissa High Court has clarified that a man cannot automatically escape prosecution for cruelty under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) merely because his relationship with a woman was not supported by a legally valid marriage.

Justice R.K. Pattanaik made the observation while partly allowing a criminal revision petition filed by Hari Krushna Mahanty. The Court held that a long-term live-in relationship possessing the essential characteristics of marriage may fall within the scope of Section 498A IPC.

The ruling arose from allegations made by a woman who claimed that she had married Mahanty in a temple in December 2011 and subsequently lived with him as his wife for approximately four to five years. She alleged that he subjected her to physical abuse and eventually forced her to leave.

Mahanty challenged the trial court's refusal to discharge him, arguing that there was no legally valid marriage between them.

The High Court declined to accept the absence of a legally valid marriage as sufficient grounds to discharge him from the cruelty charge.

Legal Topic

Area of Law: Criminal Law

Sub-topic: Cruelty Against Women – Section 498A IPC – Live-in Relationships and Relationships in the Nature of Marriage

Core Legal Issue

The principal legal question was whether a person involved in a long-term live-in relationship can face prosecution under Section 498A IPC when the relationship has the characteristics of marriage, even if the parties do not have a legally valid marriage.

The Court also considered whether the accused could obtain discharge at the preliminary stage of criminal proceedings merely by disputing the legal validity of the alleged marriage, despite allegations of prolonged cohabitation and cruelty.

What Did the Court Decide?

The High Court partly allowed the revision petition and refused to discharge Mahanty from the charge under Section 498A IPC.

The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Dr. Lokesh B.H. v. State of Karnataka (2026), which recognised that Section 498A can extend to certain live-in relationships that have the attributes of marriage.

The Court explained that the following circumstances may be relevant in determining whether a relationship qualifies:

  • The parties voluntarily and continuously lived together for a considerable period.

  • They shared a household and maintained domestic arrangements.

  • They publicly presented themselves as a couple.

  • The relationship involved an intention to marry or circumstances in which one party was led to believe that a legally recognised marriage existed.

The Court also clarified that merely ending or abandoning a non-marital relationship does not, by itself, constitute cruelty under Section 498A.

Relief granted to the petitioner: The Court discharged Mahanty from the charge under Section 313 IPC, relating to causing miscarriage, because the prosecution material did not contain corroborative medical evidence or other sufficient material establishing the alleged miscarriage and connecting it to his actions.

However, the remaining charges were allowed to proceed to trial.

Key Legal Points

  • Marriage-like relationships can attract Section 498A: A legally valid marriage is not the only basis for prosecution where the relationship satisfies the conditions recognised by the Supreme Court.

  • Nature of the relationship matters: Long-term cohabitation, shared domestic arrangements and an intention to marry are relevant considerations.

  • Disputed marriage requires examination: The accused cannot secure discharge merely by denying the marriage when the prosecution material raises issues requiring trial.

  • Cruelty must be established: The mere breakdown or abandonment of a live-in relationship does not automatically amount to criminal cruelty.

  • Medical corroboration in miscarriage charges: The Court found insufficient material to proceed under Section 313 IPC in the absence of supporting medical or other corroborative evidence.

Relevant Law

Section 498A, Indian Penal Code, 1860

This provision deals with cruelty by a husband or his relatives against a woman. The Supreme Court's interpretation in Dr. Lokesh B.H. v. State of Karnataka extends its application to qualifying relationships in the nature of marriage, subject to the prescribed conditions.

Section 313, Indian Penal Code, 1860

Deals with causing miscarriage without the woman's consent.

Section 227, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973

Empowers a Sessions Court to discharge an accused when there is insufficient ground to proceed against them.

Sections 397 and 401, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973

Provide revisional jurisdiction to the High Court to examine the legality and correctness of subordinate court orders.

Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar (2014)

The Supreme Court laid down safeguards concerning arrest in cases involving Section 498A. The Orissa High Court referred to these safeguards while discussing prosecution in qualifying live-in relationships.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner – Hari Krushna Mahanty

The petitioner argued that no legally valid marriage had taken place between him and the informant. He contended that the absence of proof of marriage meant that the essential requirements of Section 498A IPC were not satisfied.

He also challenged the allegations relating to miscarriage, assault and criminal intimidation, arguing that the prosecution lacked sufficient supporting evidence.

Respondent – State of Odisha

The State opposed the discharge application and submitted that the FIR, statements and charge-sheet materials disclosed a prima facie case.

It argued that the allegations concerning the marriage, subsequent cohabitation and cruelty justified proceeding with the criminal trial.

Why Does It Matter?

The ruling is significant because it addresses the legal protection available to women in long-term relationships that function like marriages.

Traditionally, Section 498A IPC was understood in the context of legally recognised marriages. The Supreme Court's interpretation, followed by the Orissa High Court, recognises that certain relationships resembling marriage may also fall within its protection.

The decision has several practical implications:

  • Protection for women: Women in qualifying live-in relationships may seek criminal remedies against cruelty, even where the legal validity of their marriage is disputed.

  • Greater legal accountability: A person cannot automatically avoid prosecution by denying a marriage when the relationship and surrounding circumstances satisfy the applicable legal requirements.

  • Importance of evidence: The nature, duration and circumstances of cohabitation will be relevant when determining whether a relationship qualifies.

  • Safeguards against arbitrary arrest: The legal safeguards governing arrest under Section 498A must continue to be followed.

  • Separate assessment of charges: The decision demonstrates that courts must independently examine the evidence supporting each alleged offence rather than treating every allegation as established.

Importantly, the judgment does not mean that every live-in relationship automatically attracts Section 498A. The relationship must satisfy the legal requirements identified by the Supreme Court, and the allegations of cruelty must independently meet the statutory requirements.

Legal Takeaway

The Orissa High Court has reinforced that the protection under Section 498A IPC is not necessarily restricted to legally valid marriages. Qualifying live-in relationships that possess the essential attributes of marriage may also receive protection against cruelty. However, the nature of the relationship and the evidence supporting the alleged offence remain crucial.

Sources

Primary Source:

- Orissa High Court, Hari Krushna Mahanty v. State of Odisha, CRLREV No. 212 of 2024, judgment dated November 13, 2026.

Additional Sources: