Kerala High Court Declines Contempt Action Against 2017 Actress Assault Trial Judge Over Oral Courtroom Remarks
The Kerala High Court on November 17, 2026, rejected a petition filed by Advocate T.B. Mini, who represented the survivor in the high-profile 2017 actress assault case. Mini had approached the High Court seeking suo motu criminal contempt proceedings against trial judge Honey M. Varghese over oral remarks allegedly made from the bench.
According to Mini, during proceedings on January 12, 2026, Judge Varghese accused her in open court—and in the presence of journalists—of attending the trial for fewer than 10 days, sleeping during hearings, and using the courtroom as a "resting place". Mini stated that she had actually appeared in court for over 200 days and that the broadcast of these remarks led to severe online harassment and professional defamation. She moved the High Court after the Kerala Advocate General refused to grant statutory consent for contempt proceedings in April 2026.
Legal Topic
Area of Law: Contempt of Court / Constitutional Law Sub-topic: Judicial Conduct, Suo Motu Contempt Jurisdiction, and Expungement of Remarks
Core Legal Issue
The High Court was called upon to decide whether alleged oral remarks made by a presiding trial judge—which do not form part of the official written judicial record—can be formally expunged or trigger suo motu criminal contempt proceedings against the judicial officer after the Advocate General has declined sanction. Additionally, the court had to consider whether it could issue directions to remove media reports covering those alleged courtroom exchanges.
What Did the Court / Authority Decide?
Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan dismissed Advocate T.B. Mini’s petition. While the detailed written judgment is still awaited, the dismissal ends the petitioner's attempt to initiate contempt action or seek judicial expungement of the alleged comments.
During earlier hearings before reserving the verdict, the bench had orally questioned how a constitutional court could expunge remarks that were never recorded in the official judicial order or transcript. The court had also pointed out that if the petitioner’s primary grievance stemmed from media coverage and broadcast of the remarks, her appropriate remedy lay in approaching the Press Council of India rather than seeking writ or contempt directions.
Key Legal Points
-
Limits of Expungement: Higher courts generally exercise the power to expunge adverse remarks only when those observations are formally recorded in a written order or judgment, rather than unrecorded oral exchanges in court.
-
Threshold for Criminal Contempt: The Advocate General had earlier ruled that even if the judge's alleged comments were accurate, using "excessive or extravagant language" from the bench does not automatically meet the statutory threshold for criminal contempt.
-
Alternate Remedies for Media Coverage: Grievances regarding the reporting or broadcasting of courtroom exchanges by news outlets fall under regulatory bodies like the Press Council of India rather than contempt jurisdiction.
-
Discretion in Suo Motu Cognizance: While a High Court possesses inherent constitutional power to initiate contempt proceedings on its own motion without the Advocate General's consent, exercising that power remains strictly discretionary.
Relevant Law
-
Article 215 of the Constitution of India: Empowers every High Court to act as a court of record and punish for contempt of itself.
-
The Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (Sections 2(c) and 15): Defines criminal contempt and sets out the procedural requirement of obtaining the Advocate General's consent before a private party can initiate criminal contempt proceedings.
-
Articles 19(1)(g) and 21 of the Constitution of India: Invoked by the petitioner regarding the right to practise one's profession and the right to live with dignity and reputation.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner (Advocate T.B. Mini): The petitioner argued that the trial judge’s remarks were completely unnecessary for adjudicating the case and were not integral to the judicial process. She contended that the Advocate General's refusal to grant sanction did not curtail the High Court's inherent constitutional authority to take suo motu cognizance. Mini submitted that the public allegations violated her fundamental rights under Articles 19(1)(g) and 21, and requested that the court treat her sanction plea as "information" to initiate contempt proceedings and direct Union ministries to take down defamatory media content.
Advocate General (Prior Sanction Order): While rejecting the initial request for consent on April 22, 2026, the Advocate General observed that the alleged statements—even if taken at face value—amounted at most to "excessive or extravagant language" and fell short of the legal definition of criminal contempt under the Contempt of Courts Act.
Why Does It Matter?
This ruling highlights the clear legal boundary between courtroom friction and actionable judicial misconduct. Judges often make sharp oral observations during heated trials, and while advocates have a legitimate interest in protecting their professional standing, superior courts are reluctant to invoke extraordinary contempt powers over unrecorded verbal exchanges. At the same time, the observations made during the proceedings reinforce that lawyers and litigants aggrieved by the viral amplification of courtroom remarks must pursue remedies under media regulation frameworks rather than through contempt petitions against sitting judges.
Legal Takeaway
Oral remarks made by a judge that do not enter the official court record cannot easily be expunged, nor do they readily justify criminal contempt proceedings. When unrecorded courtroom comments lead to reputational harm through news broadcasts, the legal recourse lies against the media publishers through regulatory bodies rather than contempt action against the bench.
Sources
Primary Source: Judgment of the Kerala High Court delivered by Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan on November 17, 2026 (Detailed written copy awaited); Order of the Advocate General of Kerala dated April 22, 2026.
Additional Sources: LiveLaw, Times of India, and Bar & Bench reports on the Kerala High Court proceedings (November 2026).