National

Delhi Consumer Commission Holds Bank Liable for Unauthorised Transactions, Orders Refund With Interest and Compensation

By The Legal Alpha Web Desk 20 November 2026 5 min read
Delhi Consumer Commission Holds Bank Liable for Unauthorised Transactions, Orders Refund With Interest and Compensation

The Delhi Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has ruled in favour of a woman whose bank account was debited through unauthorised online transactions, holding the bank responsible for deficiency in service.

The dispute arose after ₹77,114 was withdrawn from the woman's account through three transactions conducted on July 4, 5 and 9, 2016. The woman maintained that she had not authorised these transactions and was experiencing problems with her mobile phone during the relevant period.

She also alleged that she did not receive timely SMS alerts informing her about the disputed transactions. According to her complaint, she became aware of the transactions through a delayed notification and immediately approached the bank to report the matter and request that further transactions be blocked.

The woman also lodged a police complaint. However, after the bank declined to refund the disputed amount, she approached the consumer forum seeking relief.

Area of Law

Area of Law: Consumer Protection Law and Banking Law

Sub-topic: Unauthorised Electronic Banking Transactions and Deficiency in Banking Services

Core Legal Issue

The central legal question was whether a bank could avoid liability for unauthorised electronic transactions merely by alleging that the account holder's OTP or banking credentials had been compromised.

The Commission also had to consider the protection available to bank customers under the Reserve Bank of India's framework governing liability in unauthorised electronic banking transactions, particularly where the bank failed to establish negligence on the customer's part.

What Did the Consumer Commission Decide?

The Commission ruled in favour of the account holder and held the bank deficient in providing banking services.

It directed the bank to refund ₹70,084, representing the disputed transaction carried out on July 9, 2016. The amount is to carry interest at 7% per annum from the date of the transaction until payment.

The bank was further directed to pay ₹20,000 as compensation and ₹5,000 towards litigation expenses, taking the additional compensation and costs to ₹25,000.

The Commission's relief was confined to the ₹70,084 transaction rather than the entire ₹77,114 claimed by the woman.

Key Legal Points

  • Bank's responsibility: Banks cannot automatically shift liability to customers by claiming that OTPs or debit card details were compromised.

  • Burden of proof: Under the RBI's customer-protection framework, the bank bears the burden of establishing customer liability in unauthorised electronic banking transactions.

  • Zero-liability protection: Customers may be entitled to zero liability where the fraud results from the bank's negligence, fraud or deficiency, or a qualifying third-party breach reported within the prescribed period.

  • Importance of reporting: Promptly informing the bank and maintaining written records of complaints can be crucial in establishing a consumer's case.

  • Documentary evidence: Emails, bank correspondence, transaction records and police complaints can help establish that the customer disputed the transactions and took timely action.

Relevant Law

Reserve Bank of India Circular dated July 6, 2017

Customer Protection – Limiting Liability of Customers in Unauthorised Electronic Banking Transactions (RBI/2017-18/15).

The circular establishes the framework for determining customer liability in unauthorised electronic banking transactions.

Important provisions include:

  • Paragraph 6: Zero liability of customers in specified circumstances.

  • Paragraph 7: Limited liability where customer negligence or delayed reporting is established.

  • Paragraph 12: Places the burden of proving customer liability on the bank.

Consumer Protection Act, 2019

The consumer protection framework provides remedies against deficiency in services and allows consumers to seek compensation for losses and resulting harm.

Arguments of the Parties

The Consumer's Arguments

The woman, identified as Varsha, maintained that she had not authorised the disputed transactions and that problems with her mobile phone prevented her from receiving timely transaction alerts.

She submitted that she promptly approached Canara Bank after discovering the disputed debits, requested the blocking of further transactions and also lodged a police complaint.

She sought reimbursement of the disputed amount along with interest, compensation and other consequential expenses.

The Bank's Arguments

Canara Bank denied responsibility for transferring money to third parties.

It argued that the responsibility for protecting OTPs and card details rested with the account holder. The bank also relied on the fact that the customer had not received OTPs because of problems with her mobile phone.

However, according to the reported decision, the bank failed to produce documentary evidence establishing negligence on the customer's part.

Why Does It Matter?

The decision highlights an important aspect of consumer protection in digital banking: customers should not automatically be held responsible whenever fraudulent transactions take place through their bank accounts.

Banks are expected to maintain effective security mechanisms, monitor suspicious transactions and provide accessible channels through which customers can report unauthorised activity.

The ruling also demonstrates the importance of maintaining documentary evidence when challenging a bank's refusal to reimburse fraudulent transactions.

For consumers, the practical lesson is to report suspicious debits immediately, obtain a written acknowledgement from the bank and preserve all relevant communications.

For banks, the decision reinforces the importance of examining fraud complaints on their merits rather than relying solely on allegations that customers may have compromised their credentials.

Legal Takeaway

A bank cannot escape responsibility for unauthorised electronic transactions merely by alleging that a customer's OTP or card details were compromised. The applicable RBI framework places the burden of establishing customer liability on the bank. Prompt reporting and documentary evidence can play an important role in securing consumer relief.

Sources

Primary Source:

- Reserve Bank of India, Circular RBI/2017-18/15 dated July 6, 2017 — Customer Protection – Limiting Liability of Customers in Unauthorised Electronic Banking Transactions.

- Delhi Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission order dated October 30, 2026, as reported in the available news coverage. The full original order was not independently located.

Additional Sources: