National

Storing or Selling Spurious Goods Under a Corporate Brand Does Not Per Se Constitute Cheating: Bombay High Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings

By The Legal Alpha Web Desk 9 November 2026 5 min read
Storing or Selling Spurious Goods Under a Corporate Brand Does Not Per Se Constitute Cheating: Bombay High Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings

The Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court has stepped in to clarify the dividing line between trademark infringement offences and the general criminal charge of cheating under the Indian Penal Code. The dispute arose after an investigating officer representing brand-protection agency EIPR (India) Pvt. Ltd., acting on behalf of JSW Steel Ltd., initiated criminal proceedings against a local trader, Shadab Sheikh Qayyum Sheikh.

The trader was accused of stocking and selling spurious steel products bearing the registered trademark and name of JSW Steel Ltd. Following the complaint, an FIR was registered invoking provisions under the Trade Marks Act, 1999 alongside general penal provisions. Shadab Sheikh moved the High Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure seeking to quash the FIR and subsequent proceedings, arguing that the police failed to comply with statutory pre-conditions and that basic trade-mark disputes cannot be casually dressed up as criminal cheating.

Legal Topic

Area of Law: Intellectual Property & Criminal Law

Sub-topic: Trademark Infringement / Search & Seizure Mandates under Section 115 / Cheating under General Criminal Law

Core Legal Issue

The primary question before the High Court was whether the possession, stocking, or sale of counterfeit goods bearing a company’s registered brand name automatically attracts an offence of cheating under the Indian Penal Code (or Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita), and whether investigative authorities can bypass the mandatory procedural safeguards stipulated under Section 115(4) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999—such as obtaining the opinion of the Registrar of Trade Marks and adherence to officer ranks—by simply fastening general IPC charges to the case.

What Did the Court Decide?

Justice M. W. Chandwani allowed the criminal application and quashed the impugned criminal proceedings against the applicant.

The High Court ruled that merely storing or selling goods bearing the trademark or name of an established corporation does not fulfill the essential ingredients of cheating in the absence of evidence demonstrating dishonest inducement of any consumer or purchaser. The bench observed that intellectual property violations are governed by specific statutory regimes that contain built-in procedural safeguards. Because the authorities failed to comply with the statutory requirements under the Trade Marks Act, the prosecution could not be sustained by mechanically superimposing general offences.

Key Legal Points

  • Distinction Between IP Infringement and Deceit: The mere recovery or possession of counterfeit goods bearing a corporate logo or brand name does not automatically establish cheating under ordinary penal law unless there is tangible proof of fraudulent or dishonest inducement of a buyer.

  • Mandatory Procedure Under Section 115: Section 115(4) of the Trade Marks Act provides explicit safeguards governing police action—including the rank of the officer authorized to conduct searches and seizures and the mandatory opinion from the Registrar of Trade Marks before executing such operations.

  • No Circumvention via General Provisions: Investigating agencies and brand owners cannot evade the statutory safeguards built into the Trade Marks Act by simply tacking general penal provisions (such as Section 420 IPC) onto the complaint.

  • Curative Role of Section 482 CrPC: Where the initiation of criminal proceedings violates express statutory provisions or constitutes an abuse of process, the High Court is obligated to exercise its inherent powers to quash the prosecution.

Relevant Law

  • Trade Marks Act, 1999:

    • Section 103 (Penalty for applying false trade marks, trade descriptions, etc.)

    • Section 104 (Penalty for selling goods to which a false trade mark or false trade description is applied)

    • Section 115 (Cognizance of offences, search and seizure procedures, and statutory prerequisites)

  • Indian Penal Code, 1860:

    • Section 415 & Section 420 (Cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property)

  • Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973:

    • Section 482 (Inherent powers of the High Court to prevent abuse of process)

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant (Shadab Sheikh Qayyum Sheikh)

The applicant contended that the raid and subsequent criminal action were completely illegal because the police bypassed the mandatory procedural requirements outlined in Section 115 of the Trade Marks Act. Counsel argued that no buyer or victim had come forward alleging deception or dishonest inducement, meaning the foundational elements of cheating could not be made out. The applicant submitted that adding general criminal charges was a tactical maneuver by the complainant to bypass the statutory threshold of trademark law.

Respondent (State of Maharashtra & Complainant / JSW Steel's Representative)

The State and the complainant argued that the applicant was engaged in an unauthorized commercial enterprise involving counterfeit goods carrying JSW Steel Ltd.’s registered mark, thereby causing economic harm to the brand and deceiving the public at large. They submitted that possessing and distributing counterfeit goods of an established commercial brand naturally amounts to dishonest conduct warranting criminal prosecution under both special and general laws.

Why Does It Matter?

This ruling reinforces procedural discipline in intellectual property disputes in India. Private brand-protection agencies and corporate right-holders frequently resort to filing police complaints that bundle generic cheating sections to trigger quick arrests, raids, or commercial leverage.

By holding that counterfeit possession alone does not constitute cheating, and by enforcing strict adherence to the procedural guardrails of Section 115 of the Trade Marks Act, the Bombay High Court has curbed the practice of bypassing trademark law’s built-in statutory checks. The judgment provides vital guidance for downstream traders and retailers against arbitrary police searches while warning corporate brand managers that anti-counterfeiting crackdowns must strictly comply with special statutory procedures.

Legal Takeaway

Possessing or selling counterfeit goods bearing a corporate brand does not automatically establish the offence of cheating under general penal law without concrete evidence of consumer deception. Furthermore, law enforcement cannot circumvent the mandatory statutory safeguards of the Trade Marks Act by simply adding general fraud provisions to an FIR.

Sources

  • Primary Source: Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench), Shadab Sheikh Qayyum Sheikh v. State of Maharashtra & Anr., Criminal Application [APL] No. 918 of 2026, Neutral Citation: 2026:BHC-NAG:15223 (Judgment by Chandwani, J.).

  • Additional Sources: The Trade Marks Act, 1999 (Act No. 47 of 1999); High Court of Judicature at Bombay Case Information System.